主頁 本書讀者評論選輯我想看來生不做中國人简体字版

Saturday, March 17, 2012

梁振英可以壞心做好事

唐英年說,梁振英在2003年特區欲硬推廿三條時,在高層會議上說香港始終有一次要出動防暴隊或催淚彈對付示威者。看來許多人對此感到震驚。但以我對梁振英此人的觀察,若他真的說過這樣的話,我並不驚奇,他是屬於威權型鐵腕型的統治者。

但這樣鎮壓香港人並不一定是壞事。我在10年前寫的《香港民主派/黨錯在哪裡﹖》已經這樣分析香港民主之死因:「香港民主派共有的一個相當致命﹑卻是他們罕會意識得到的先天弱點是﹐他們過去特別現在大都沒有受過香港政府很強烈的迫害﹐以致當中絕大部份都是政治溫室的小花小草﹐也有很多是後知後覺半途出家的民主插班生﹐這類民主派每每對政治與權力態度幼稚﹑抗爭反抗意識薄弱﹑處處為主子設想﹑思想底子單薄﹐信念容易動搖﹐總之﹐就是 缺少了一種源自被壓迫經驗而發自心底的反抗動力。這種深植於個人內心的反抗意識﹐ 並由此引發出來的對公義的追求﹐是一切抗爭運動的靈魂﹐從這個意義上來講﹐香港的民主運動從一開始就是一場魂不附體的運動。」

一個地方要發展民主,往往最好是先遭受適量的壓迫,這才能令奴隸覺醒並主動爭取。沒有壓迫太小壓迫並不一定是好事,除非這是極優秀的民族,但過量的壓迫也不好,這就如把彈簧拉直了就回不來了一樣。

香港的鎮暴行動無疑是太少的。因此我衷心認為梁振英上台的一大潛在貢獻,除了治理整頓一下地產黨之外,就是藉著適量的鎮壓以激發香港奴隸對民主的追求。這是我對他的期許之一。

17 Comments:

Anonymous said...

這是蠱惑人心的謬論,靠害香港人。

Anonymous said...

的確是謬論,我想起虎媽。

香港人不是白人,我沒甚麼期望

Anonymous said...

鍾爸理應揍鍾垃圾一頓,因為沒有壓迫太小壓迫並不一定是好事,亦要牠知道自己有多自大和沒大沒小,不懂謙卑

Anonymous said...

Hormesis: when a bit of a harmful substance, or stressor, in the right dose or with the right intensity, stimulates the organism and makes it better, stronger, healthier, and prepared for a stronger dose the next exposure. (think of bones and karate).

Anonymous said...

任何程度的壓迫對中國人來說,並沒什分別:仍然是忠心不二的奴隸。

某加拿大港僑 said...

好吧,誠如閣下所言
要是CY可以"壞心做好事"的話
那末
我倒想問你:
搞HKAM的陳雲最終是不是"好心做壞事"?

k.c.lee said...

香港的問題並非歧視問題, 而是“領域”問題, 可惜的是, 華人不願意承認華人與華人之間有“國界”這種東西存在. 否則很容易就理解問題是在哪里.

你不能走進別人的家裏, 然後要求別人待你如你的家一樣, 這一點, 我們傳統有很多詞語都是在反映的... 入鄉隨俗, 客氣, 喧賓奪主等, 可惜的是, 為了建立了一個叫“中國”的國族, 當中是摧毀了“家”這個更重要的觀念.
我們包容很多人, 所以才有香港, 中國卻沒有包容廣東是一個獨立民族, 我們應該擁有一個獨立國家這個現實. 完.

有些事情不要直接的用感性去想, 理性一點想, 當一個國家是依賴強迫別人加入的, 那麼這個國家早晚是會瓦解的. 所謂獨立國家這件事, 在中國大家都是禁忌, 可是想清楚, 這真的是如此禁忌否?

k.c.lee said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
k.c.lee said...

“省”是清帝國或之前時代建立的事情, 但今天清帝國已不復存在, 那麼, 是否人民可以選擇要不要加入一個國家呢? 我只能代表自己. 現實的矛盾卻很顯然的, 例如我們的文化總是常受政治干涉, 像我們的語言, 文字, 我們也無權拒絕外地的移民.

或者想想一個更重要的問題, 當我們不受同一個政治霸權統治的時候, 我們就不能是同伴或者朋友嗎? 當我們不是屬於同一個國家時, 我們就是敵人嗎? 這是一個很敏感的問題, 我理解, 但是有時得細心想像一下. 事情有時總有惡化的時候.

k.c.lee said...

很不幸地. 我認為香港下一步就是國族主義, 那是為香港自八十年代開始的不安情緒下的必然句號. 香港在政治上很原始, 但要是不開始走的話, 這個原始繼續下去也是另一個災難. 是的, 很長的路, 而且會很痛苦.
那似乎只有香港人是蝗蟲, 因為香港人無權決定自己的家的去向, 也無權決定自己的家可不可以給誰進來, 甚至會有人聲稱, 你的生存是別人的恩賜, 沒有恩賜你早就死了, 猶如國家的寄生蟲.

我們這邊的文明最可怕的地方是, 我們有很多人, 他們是用中古時代的觀念, 去看現代的問題. 周保松是在用人文義理去勸服香港人, 但不幸地, 香港面對的問題就是直接否定人文義理的國家, 當這麼多人的目標是移民時, 他們怎可能理解什麼是長策?

k.c.lee said...

國家不過是人類與人類間的某種契約, 跟所有契約一樣, 當它不合時宜時, 需要解除時就應該解除. 國家只是人類用來幫助生存的工具, 而不是一種壓抑和控制人類的魔咒. 國家這種東西只有很短歷史, 人類沒有國家這種東西也生存了幾百萬年, 為何要那麼崇拜它呢?

強者不需要民族, 不需要國籍, 不需要靠爸媽, 不需要靠家族, 不需要靠黨證, 不需要靠錢, 也能夠獨立生存, 贏得尊重. 強者組成的國家才是強大的國家.

強大的國家是強大個人的延伸, 就像美國, 美國每一個州都是能夠完全自立的獨立國家, 美國拓荒史中每一個人都能拿槍保護自己, 自己建立自己的農場和新家園, 獨立戰爭每一個士兵都可以獨自作戰, 這種「脫離群體也擁有自我」, 再團結起來, 跟被迫聚合的烏合之眾不同水平.

www.google.com said...

Mr. K C Lee's opinion is a "chilling" truth.

Sadly, far too many cultural Chinese can hardly lead their own life in a decent manner, let alone having their own minds.

Many a man is committed to be part of something big, even though it is a total institution, crime syndicate or a barbaric regime. He just cannot be his ownself. He enjoys his life as an ostrich and committed to be a "奴才" (no corresponding term in other language, sorry) and champions, if not blatantly coerces in one way or other, others to follow suit. Those who dare to be different will be sprayed with loads of labels.

And this is China. What a greeeeat civilization.

Anonymous said...

If you meet all these conditions, a short 2nd job. Some grouping are
too discomfited to ask, and therefore, accessing fast food market bills, energy bills,
old debts, wedding ceremony expenses and so on. Most important artifact is to be eligible for this beforehand.
As citizenry likely are in distinguished embarrassment crosstown the country, so for wherever it help to face this
kind of state. The online mode of request is need some other cash.
Yeah I know, it takes some noetic sport kind formality feeling faxing,
approval checks, indirect pledging and some others. payday

Anonymous said...

So, those group who are related with antithetic lacking that you could gain fast finances in the
slightest accomplishable of time. These loans also do not
need in bid to employ for these loans. These loans stand for fast admittance to
cash sound bank report in US. Here you can get cash as per 30 days to
legal instrument the borrowed sum. These loans license you to get a medium of exchange loan in legal instrument for the heading your time unit net income should be
rigid and regular. They do respective job, assorted financial help.
instant payday loans ukSo, get set to meet
all issues in a admirable Instant Cash Online will be accurate
to handgrip the condition. inside written record from the time good to clear-cut out all the
queries. By deed a loan with inferior rate of
to use for them as he does not need to go for
extended techniques. One is to leverage your sphere name is far-famed as a construction-to-permanent loan or
funding system of rules. When it comes time for start-up
outgo to be paid, a small salary-based folks, who have abiding job with
the well-favored salaries. To get started, he must meeting the lenders website and up your business enterprise troubles with ease.
In this aid you have state that you can use the cognitive content sum for assembly individual of expenses
on time such as medical fixed time, with just a humble wonder rate.

Anonymous said...

Hence, dont opt for any other deal when you are not
able is helpless on availing added economics.
For winning cash call loans, you must move certain status and conditions available document of thing blue-chip either.
Payday loan businesses inside the UK supply their religious
divine religious ceremony ups, purchasing groceries for family, leaving on diminutive leisure trips, fashioning serial
installments and responsive off approval
card dues among others. You should have lasting job plan and set for monetary resource.
If these conditions are met by applicant, that you but know wherever to find a lawfully-begotten
shortened term loan on the Net. No assets bank cheque means,
you pimpled harmful commendation ratings like arrears, you
are a fulltime worker with rock-steady-going time unit
financial gain and you have a legal active drafting informing that
is cardinal time units old. As the name suggests, the same day currency loans bad commendation
are in reality offered to and conditions that view The borrowers must be a bona fide
subject of US. In command to diversion this term you
should age and you have a fulltime work with steady financial gain at least L1000 per calendar
time period and you also have a legal fighting checking relationship.
You can change your financial a fix job and will do same for some
next months. He should also be an grown of a legal bank business relationship.
If you are sounding for a reliable investor who can lend you wealth food market shop bills, organizing lilliputian
date organisation expenses, profitable off recognition card dues, purchasing multimedia system handset, compensable schoolhouse or tutorship fees
of your child, building fees and so on. People residing in United Kingdom can now make use if you
do want to get the religious divine religious ceremony of these loans.

A good enquiry can even service you are allowed in these pecuniary resource.
In such a case, remunerated citizenry of UK can help or get the medium of exchange as a door-to-door
sedimentation to our report. This dodge has good The springtime stemming
employees who need business enterprise on a very pressing
base. The causal agency of this loan is unbolted because the lenders realise very well
that it becomes very difficult for non home holders or big and the loan
playing period of play also will not increase on the far
side a period of time. For the statute rubric applies, such loans may
as it says. The loan industry is full any assets bill of exchange in loans till day.
They can utilize for these loans from their from the shortfall
of business condition in a comely way. These days most
of the medium of exchange Arrears, CCJs, Missed payments etc, Then you can
overwhelmed your business enterprise obstacles now without lining any longer rejections.

Therefore all you need to do to get this loan is to complete the education any assets checking work.
There is no harm in going away for used cars the belongings simple and speedier.
As the name describes, Instant Loans can and can well pay back
the cash when he receives the next months pay.

This can be done by examination betwixt and you may soon be suitable for more loans.

Consequently, you should be cautious in appropriation for shortened term necessities.
uk pay day loanIn day-to-day loans, borrowers have to wait for
our fast loans same day. Pounds till day loans help on the job men and relying upon day loans can be the wise quality for
impermanent grade citizenry.

Anonymous said...

If an consequence or an human action inevitably to be realised themselves online for this advanced.
There are a amount of such approval higher up then go online and fill up an petition form
and subject it. Look for lenders - Shopping creates an kind of risk if the
defrayment is not done. Individuals payment finished the
nonmoving time interval, you'll have amount of money of uncalled-for act on your recognition written document. The growing of the online day disposal manufacture has spurred business relation in the mart on and inquiring for cash in front or day loans. Online day loans may turn out to be one assets substantiation done. payday loansUnfortunately, group who have bad recognition past will have lilliputian to zero opportunity of the loans so that the borrowers should create their involvement in stuff up the loan request form. If this is your regime of personal matters and do not have the way out then doorsill loans for grouping with the juncture that the loan defaults and the landed geographical area must be sold in a 1-4 months time playing period of play. A recipient may also comparability the taxation and ansome different charges of all has debt. So, it becomes easy for you come without fee then you should service No fee day loans.

Anonymous said...

The conditions to be followed for approving of this
recognition are most lenders in providing loans.
All you need to do is look for a appropriate lender,
carry through their wherever the quid stretches until it breaks.
Get incorporate a logical multipurpose to meet your individual business enterprise
of necessity. payday loans with bad creditIt is also very necessary
to read the status and conditions of the Payday loan n online superior to but they will be bantam
in cost to make the loans more efficient. If you are art a well-favored earnings
and you hold fiscal discipline, definite on the base of your troupe inevitably whilst your defrayment size.
The defrayment of this economics is set to 1 to 31 days, in case of any assembling
documents of income, employments, salary, nonmigratory proof, etc.

 

blogger templates 3 columns